NDT vs. NBI: Implications for Deck Maintenance and Rehabilitation

As a part of the biennial routine bridge inspections, visual inspection data is obtained for each of the major elements of a bridge, including the deck. This information, reported in the National Bridge Inventory (NBI), is generally used to assign and prioritize specific actions, ranging from minor repairs to full deck replacement. Bridge deck deterioration, however, occurs below the surface and is not apparent visually until significant damage has occurred. Therefore, this visual inspection data does not provide the important subsurface condition information essential to making cost effective maintenance, rehabilitation, and preservation decisions. Given this limitation, an increasing number of agencies are now using subsurface scanning methods such as Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) and Infrared Thermography (IR). This paper provides a case study which examines the implications of decisions made solely based on NBI type rating data versus decisions made including subsurface data from deck scanning. The study is based on a group of 57 bridge decks recently scanned in Southwest Michigan. The decks have been analyzed for percent deterioration using either GPR, IR, or both. The deterioration quantities derived from these methods are compared to the NBI ratings. Using this comparison, the study shows that, using NBI data alone, deck condition estimates and resulting rehabilitation decisions would often be inappropriate for the actual condition of the structure, and the resulting life cycle costs are significantly higher.

1. ASTM "Standard Test Method for Detecting Delaminations in Bridge Decks Using Infrared Thermography", Designation D4788-97, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, 2005. 2. ASTM “Standard Test Method for Evaluating Asphalt-Covered Concrete Bridge Decks Using Ground Penetrating Radar” Designation D 6087-05, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA, 2005. 3. Maser, K., Carmichael, A. Johnson, B., Keranen, P. , Holdhusen, B. and Green, D. "Network Level Bridge Deck Condition Assessment in Minnesota". from Proceedings of the Conference on NDT/NDE for Highways and Bridges, New York, NY 4. MDOT Bridge Deck Preservation Matrix. Michigan Department of Transportation, "Bridge Operations Manuals & Guidelines, " 2014. (Online). Available: (http://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdot/ MDOT_ BridgeDeckMatrix _withUncoatedBlackRebar_355077_7.pdf (Accessed January 2014). 5. MDOT Bridge Repair Cost Estimate Worksheet. Michigan Department of Transportation, "Bridge Operations Forms and Reports, " 2014 (Online) Available at: http://www.michigan.gov/mdot/0,4616,7-151- 9625_24768_59520---,00.html. (Accessed February 2014).
Usage Shares
Total Views
18 Page Views
Total Shares
0 Tweets
0 PDF Downloads
0 Facebook Shares
Total Usage